Call Us: 631-727-2180

Navigating a Contested Divorce in Suffolk County, New York

Marina Martielli

Navigating a Contested Divorce in Suffolk County, New York

What happens after you or your spouse says, “I want a divorce”?

Divorce can be scary, angry, and sad. However, if it is something you want or your spouse has requested, there are certain questions you should ask yourself and things you should know. This article covers four primary issues in a contested divorce: child custody, child support, maintenance, and equitable distribution of property.

Contested vs. Uncontested Divorces

There are two types of divorce: uncontested and contested.  Generally, an uncontested divorce is when you and your spouse have been able to sit down, discuss and agree about children, if any, and the division of real and personal property you have accumulated during the marriage.  An uncontested divorce still requires Court intervention and the filing of a “divorce packet”, which contains all the documents you and your spouse need to complete, sign, and file for a fee with the Court.  However, an “uncontested” divorce may require mediation and even attorneys on both sides assisting the parties with negotiations and settlement.

Uncontested divorces will not be covered in more depth in this article.

Contested Divorce

A contested divorce is where you and your spouse do not agree about the issues that must be settled in order to obtain a Judgment of Divorce.  These issues include residential custody of children and child support; maintenance (“spousal support” or “alimony”); and the division of marital property (called “equitable distribution”).

Residential Custody

If you have children, and if they are under the age of 18, and/or still attending grades K -12, or may even be attending college, residential custody and child support will or may need to be determined.

Determining factors in residential custody include which parent can best provide for the children physically and emotionally; which offers the most stable environment; which is likely to encourage parenting time with the other parent; and the children’s preferences.

A parent with whom the children primarily live while they are attending school or even college is the “residential” or “custodial” parent.  Generally, the “nonresidential” or “noncustodial” parent will have “parenting time” with the children primarily on alternate weekends, one or two dinners during the week after school, holidays, school breaks, and during the summer.*

Exceptions to this include 1) whether both parents live close enough to enable joint or shared residential custody; or 2) whether issues exist that will prevent one parent from having unsupervised time with the children.  (This would necessitate the involvement of Child Protective Services (“CPS”) and will not be covered in more depth in this article.)

Joint or shared custody may be an option if you live close enough or in the same school district and getting the children to and from school is manageable for both.  For instance, you can agree to a week on/week off schedule, exchanging the children on Sunday evenings, and also agree to a schedule governing holidays, school breaks, birthdays, and summer vacations.

If you don’t or won’t live close to each other or within the same school district, and if you can’t agree on who should have residential custody or the parenting time of the nonresidential parent, the Court will most likely appoint an Attorney for the Children (an “AFC”).

An AFC is a private attorney who practices in Suffolk County and is on a list of attorneys willing to act in such capacity.  AFCs in divorce cases in Supreme Court are paid for by you and your spouse, proportionally, at an hourly rate of approximately $400.00.  If you make 25% of the household income and your spouse makes 75%, you would pay 25% of the AFC’s fee and your spouse would pay 75%.

If an AFC is appointed, he or she will be meeting privately with the children to determine their preferences and will also be looking for “coaching” from over-zealous parents; whether or not either parent is making derogatory remarks about the other in front of or to the children; and will try to get a clear picture of what is happening in each household.  As an attorney who has served in such capacity, it is not difficult to determine whether a child has been coached and the reluctance of children to respond to questions is telling.  It is best to treat and refer to your soon-to-be ex-spouse with respect, especially in front of your children.  The standard in custody cases is the best interest of the children.  Despite the tensions that arise in divorce, acting in your children’s best interest will only be to your benefit.  An AFC’s assessment of the situation, based on his or her discussions with the children, is generally taken very seriously by the Court.  But an AFC has an attorney/client relationship with the children.  Everything the children say to the AFC is confidential and the AFC will act accordingly.

Child Support

Child support is generally paid to the parent who has residential custody of the children (the custodial parent) by the parent with whom the children do not primarily live (the noncustodial parent), and the amount is determined based on the income of both parents and the number of children.  If the noncustodial parent earns more than the custodial parent, the noncustodial parent will pay a certain percentage of his or her income to the custodial parent.  For instance, if there is one child, and the noncustodial parent is the “monied” spouse, he or she will pay 17% of his or her income as and for child support.

Child support is paid on a weekly or monthly basis.  If the noncustodial parent cannot be relied upon to pay regularly, the child support amount may be garnished directly from his or her salary by the Child Support Collection Unit.

Failure to pay child support after an Order from the Court has been issued may be punishable by suspension or revocation of one’s driver’s license and even incarceration for up to six (6) months for contempt of Court.  The monied spouse may also have to pay arrears beginning from the time he or she left the marital residence if he or she failed to continue to contribute to the financial support of the children voluntarily.

Generally, where the parties have agreed to joint or shared custody, neither parent pays child support to the other.

Maintenance

Maintenance or spousal support (formerly known as alimony) is designed to provide temporary financial support to the “non-monied” spouse.  The aim is to help make that spouse self-sufficient.  Determining factors the Court uses are the length of the marriage; the age and health of the spouses; the earning capacity of each spouse; and childcare, if relevant.

The length of time the non-monied spouse receives maintenance, and the amount of maintenance is up to the discretion of the Court and is determined on a case-by-case basis.  In marriages of shorter duration, however, the maintenance is generally lower and would end sooner.  Where the parties have been married for over twenty years say, generally the maintenance would be higher and could last for up to ten years or more.  Again, it depends on the circumstances of the parties and their respective incomes.

Marital Property and Equitable Distribution

Marital property (real and personal) is generally defined as property acquired during the marriage, regardless of whose name is on the title, including portions of retirement accounts accumulated during the marriage regardless of who contributed to them; a percentage of the value of businesses either started or that grew during the marriage; and all income, bonuses or commissions received during the marriage by both spouses.

Nonmarital or separate property is defined as property (real and personal) acquired or owned prior to the marriage or received as gifts or inheritances during the marriage by either spouse.  This may also apply to some personal injury awards.

Equitable distribution ensures marital property is distributed fairly, not necessarily equally.

Factors the Court looks at include the duration of the marriage; the contributions of each spouse; and the economic circumstances of each spouse.

Can separate property become marital property?  Yes.

Separate property can become marital property if an inheritance, gift or personal injury award is co-mingled in a joint checking or savings or other marital account.  Once separate property is co-mingled, it may lose its identity as separate property.  Also, if a spouse’s name is added to the deed of separate real property during the marriage, that, too, may become marital property subject to equitable distribution.

In 2016, New York State Domestic Relations Law §236(B)(5)(d)(7) was amended to exclude, as marital property, the value of a spouse’s enhanced earning capacity arising from a license, degree, celebrity goodwill or career enhancement.

Filing Fees

In New York State contested divorces generally require the following filing fees:  $210.00 for an Index Number (which you need to commence an action for divorce); $30.00 to $125.00 for a Note of Issue; $90.00 for a Request of Judicial Intervention; $35 to file a Settlement Agreement; and $8.00 to obtain a certified copy of your Judgment of Divorce.  You will also have to pay a process server for personal service of a summons with notice or summons and complaint.

In Suffolk County, New York, currently all divorce matters are assigned to Judges in the Cohalan Court Complex located in Central Islip.

In closing, divorces are not easy and can be fraught with negative emotions.  If there are children involved, especially younger children, parents should be aware that the separation will be easier on them if they witness their parents acting with as much love and respect as possible.  As many Judges and AFCs have urged parties over the years:  “Love your children more than you hate each other.”

And if there are no children?  Although love is not a word often associated with divorce, I have found that, despite the acrimony that may arise, keeping a clear head, knowing what you are entitled to, and remembering the love you once felt, will help.  My experience has been that by doing this you are taking care of yourself emotionally, which will help as you navigate a contested divorce.

*The terms residential and custodial are sometimes used interchangeably to denote the parent with whom the children primarily live.  However, custody is a legal term and generally refers to decision-making and provides the basis for which a parent may receive child support.

 

Marina Martielli is an attorney in Twomey Latham’s Divorce & Family Law and Civil Litigation departments. This publication is for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The author of this article is available to discuss its contents at your convenience.

More Articles

Join Our Team

Twomey Latham has enjoyed a steady rate of growth since it was established in 1973.

We are looking for people who share our core beliefs, passion, and dedication to the individual and corporate clients we serve.